Black Magician and Age of Five Trilogy

[j_mercuryuk]

I just think they're alittle naff, not very well written for a professional book. I don't like ANY of his characters and he seems like he's trying to be smart but failing.
_________________
"Nothing. Amazing subject, that one. Produces such fascinating reactions in people."
Founder of GRaHS-Give Rothen a Hug Society.
"We don't need drugs, we have anime"
--Guardian to Elmindreda--

“You know, Squall,� Zell said, his voice muffled, “have I ever told you what an attractive preying mantis you’d make? Seriously, you got the whole bad-boy-mantis thing down to a point –� I Made a Promise, by InstigateInsanity

[Elendor]

so now he has 4 books and hes changing it 2 the inheritance cycle!
um hello, i think thats a really crap name, agree with me?
wot about the inheritance saga or epic or anything else really!

can't wait 4 book 3! xxx

_________________
Auyara-
"I can't turn from the little I have left of my life for a made up peice of a person buried somewhere within a man I don't know."

[Ora]

He is going top write fourth book? Wow, I didn't know that.... Well, I can't wait for 3rd to come out....
_________________
Време не по�тоји, али пролази тако брзо да нам �е понекад замагли пред очима.


* * *
-Guardian of Errol-
Everything has a price

-Warrior-

[Lorlyn]

cycle is stupid. He's better off calling it series. or something with Quad since Quad means 4. Quadogy or something perhaps?
_________________
High Lady and Healer

Forum Email: blackmagicianforum@gmail.com
Forum Website: http://www.freewebs.com/bmtaofscrapbook/index.htm

[j_mercuryuk]

Cylce? That is stupid, for a start, cycle implies that there is more then one cycle in a series/world..oh dear, i hope that's not what it is!
_________________
"Nothing. Amazing subject, that one. Produces such fascinating reactions in people."
Founder of GRaHS-Give Rothen a Hug Society.
"We don't need drugs, we have anime"
--Guardian to Elmindreda--

“You know, Squall,� Zell said, his voice muffled, “have I ever told you what an attractive preying mantis you’d make? Seriously, you got the whole bad-boy-mantis thing down to a point –� I Made a Promise, by InstigateInsanity

[Ora]

yes, that really is a stupid name. I would name it serial or something like that if I were in his shoes....
_________________
Време не по�тоји, али пролази тако брзо да нам �е понекад замагли пред очима.


* * *
-Guardian of Errol-
Everything has a price

-Warrior-

[Mirar]

I think the movie was horribly insufficient.
They didn't spend enough time on it.

Compare to Lord of the Rings.
They create a 4-hour show.
So?
It's satisfying.

Eragon?
2-hour show.
Many points missed out.
Boo.

I loved the books, but was greatly disappointed with the movie. I agree with Siyee, I don't care if it's unoriginal, the books are really good!

Anyway, when is the third book scheduled for release?

And what's the fourth book's name?
_________________
_______________________

Lord Protector of the New Ones.
_______________________

A Novice of the Healing Arts.
_______________________

[j_mercuryuk]

The thing is, LotR was the exception, it's something that normally really shouldn't have been done, but it works. To be honest, I wouldn't want to sit through 4 hours of Eragon. The problem was more with the content and the way it was put together, rather then how long the film was.
_________________
"Nothing. Amazing subject, that one. Produces such fascinating reactions in people."
Founder of GRaHS-Give Rothen a Hug Society.
"We don't need drugs, we have anime"
--Guardian to Elmindreda--

“You know, Squall,� Zell said, his voice muffled, “have I ever told you what an attractive preying mantis you’d make? Seriously, you got the whole bad-boy-mantis thing down to a point –� I Made a Promise, by InstigateInsanity

[Lord Borne]

yeah i thought that the film could have been better prepared e.g. when Eragon looks through Saphira's eyes they made it a spell insted of part of their close connection and bond
_________________
HEALING NOVICE
________________________________________
Mentor of Lance
________________________________________
Star Wars nut
________________________________________

[Fayzorus Altador]

Oh sorry, I meant content density.
The two hours of Eragon were not satisfying because there wasn't enough impact to really get the audience to feel, "Wow, this is the best ever!"
Instead, they put in "weak" content, a waste of two hours. It is possible they make it real good, all in two hours, but too bad.

And Arya isn't pretty.
Talking about their cast, I think the only people whom I had expected to look like their characters were Brom and Ajihad. The rest don't look like what I expected them to be.

How sad.
_________________
________________________

Novice of the Warrior Skills
________________________

A.K.A the Healing Novice Mirar
________________________

[arwen]

loved the books, can't wait for the third to come out... BUT absolutely HATEd the movie... i was embarresed to watch the failed attempts at acting, Brom was just about the only good character.
I was also embarresed because i had convinced my friends(who don't read) that the books were awsome so i dragged them to see the movie and it was a serious let down, they thought my taste in books was sad.
_________________
Keep your swords sharp

[Lord Borne]

i took my little brother and sister on christmas eve and they enjoyed it but i never. i was let down by it but i enjoyed the books
_________________
HEALING NOVICE
________________________________________
Mentor of Lance
________________________________________
Star Wars nut
________________________________________

[Lord Borne]

the next book comes out in england on the 20th of september and is called brisingr if you wanted to know
_________________
HEALING NOVICE
________________________________________
Mentor of Lance
________________________________________
Star Wars nut
________________________________________

[Lady Laura]

I read book 1 & 2 a few years ago... I really enjoyed them! But i thought some parts were a bit drawn out.

I didnt read book 3, because I thought I wouldnt understand it, since i read the other books so long ago

I saw the film when it came out, I was quite disappointed I think they had good material to work with, but somehow still ruined it.

About Arya, I think she's good-looking! Whoever said she wasnt must have very high standards lol And I actually liked her more in the film than the book. I always thought she was arrogant in the books.
_________________
-ALCHEMIST-

** Honoured Mentor to Black Magician Sonea Nee Lady **

"Reading is one form of escape... Running for your life is another!"

[Ora]

Arya good-looking? You must be joking! I even thought she was ugly
Ah, well. Not all the opinions are the same.
_________________
Време не по�тоји, али пролази тако брзо да нам �е понекад замагли пред очима.


* * *
-Guardian of Errol-
Everything has a price

-Warrior-

[Lady Laura]

wow, ugly? That's harsh.... ok, I havnt seen the film in 3 years, maybe I've forgotten what she looks like

But id never call someone ugly She might be reading these posts and get upset! lol
_________________
-ALCHEMIST-

** Honoured Mentor to Black Magician Sonea Nee Lady **

"Reading is one form of escape... Running for your life is another!"

[Ora]

Ok, maybe I was exaggerating Not really ugly but ordinary? Something like that.
_________________
Време не по�тоји, али пролази тако брзо да нам �е понекад замагли пред очима.


* * *
-Guardian of Errol-
Everything has a price

-Warrior-

[Lady Laura]

I get what you mean.
Maybe I was kinder to her because, like I said earlier, I liked her more in the film... I really thought she acted all superior in the book, and that annoyed me...
_________________
-ALCHEMIST-

** Honoured Mentor to Black Magician Sonea Nee Lady **

"Reading is one form of escape... Running for your life is another!"

[Ora]

I didn't like her in books either. I hated what she did to Eragon and I hated him because she attracted him so much
_________________
Време не по�тоји, али пролази тако брзо да нам �е понекад замагли пред очима.


* * *
-Guardian of Errol-
Everything has a price

-Warrior-

[Lady Laura]

Exactly!!! She was such a dislikable person. I hated how Eragon was attracted to her for so long, we all knew it would never work out...

I really liked Brom in the Book, but I knew he would die. That knid of character always does!
_________________
-ALCHEMIST-

** Honoured Mentor to Black Magician Sonea Nee Lady **

"Reading is one form of escape... Running for your life is another!"