View Full Version: Black Magician vs. Age of Five

blackmagiciangr >>Trudi Canavan >>Black Magician vs. Age of Five


WinterSnake- 05-04-2007

Yuppers! I like Tryss too.

Kasloumor- 05-04-2007

Exactly - we all did I think - and then he was never mentioned at all after having survived. Why did she create him then? I don't get that.

WinterSnake- 05-04-2007

The same goes for Imi. Wasn't mentioned alot in VotG. Same to some of the Whites om VotG. Nooo! I liked Mairae!

j_mercuryuk- 05-04-2007

I didn't think that I like Tryss much, until i realised how disappionted I was about him not being in LotW. I didn't like Imi, glad to hear I won't have to put up with her in the last book.

>I.n.d.r.i.a.<- 05-07-2007

Me neither. The Elai were really boring I thought. Her parts were so annoying, I have to admit I barely paid any attention to them. I hated how we all had to read from random peoples point of view in the books, too.

Alexia- 05-08-2007

I've only read PotW but I still know which one I prefer. I did have trouble sticking with it, and found it easy enough to put down. I didn't think it had much of a plot. Perhaps the following two books do, but PotW felt like a very long introductory chapter to a book that had good potential but which I haven't quite finished reading yet!

ebony- 05-12-2007

oh yes i do agree with you there Alexia! i read like 10 chapters before i could actually get in to PotW. sucks.

WinterSnake- 05-12-2007

Well I'm different lol. I got in within the first chapter and I think the plot is very good. Well, I did finish all the books. :lol:

j_mercuryuk- 05-12-2007

I actually found LotW harder to get into then PotW.

ebony- 05-12-2007

you did??? i think i was more wiling to get into LotW as i knew it was gonna be good, cas the first one was and cas BMT was awesome too.

j_mercuryuk- 05-12-2007

I guess i just didn't like alot of the smaller plot lines.

ebony- 05-12-2007

if anything, i think thats what go me into it. i hated reading about all the boring stuff in the prolouge and the 1st few chapters of PotW.

j_mercuryuk- 05-12-2007

Well, the thinker girl's story really bored me, expect when there was the romantic bit, then I started getting interested, then she goes away and i got bored again. As for Imi...well, i kinda felt like she got what she deserved.

ebony- 05-12-2007

yeah me too. she was irritating. grrrrrr ness

j_mercuryuk- 05-12-2007

yay, someone finally agrees with me.

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.